They sound like the same job because both have "exit" energy around them. They aren't. One makes your store more valuable before you sell; the other converts that value into a closed deal. Hire the wrong one for your stage and you either pay for strategy you can't use yet, or list a store that isn't ready and watch buyers walk.
This guide is for an owner who already runs the numbers — real orders, real ad spend, a store with a history a buyer can inspect. If that's you and you're weighing an exit, start with your store's valuation before you hire anyone.
The short version: two different jobs
A business broker's purpose is a completed transaction. They get paid when the store sells, so their whole focus is finding a buyer, fielding offers, and getting to close at the best price the market will bear.
An exit planning consultant's purpose is a stronger business. They work before a sale — clarifying your goals, finding the gaps that scare buyers, and raising the store's value so that when you do list, it sells for more and closes faster.
The timing rule most owners get wrong: you start exit planning when you're not ready to sell. A consultant is useful one to three years out. A broker is useful when you're ready to list this quarter.
What an exit planning consultant actually does
Think of the consultant as the person who gets the store into sellable shape. Their work is diagnostic and preparatory, not transactional.
- Readiness assessment. They pressure-test the business the way a buyer's due diligence will: Is the revenue concentrated in one product? Does the store depend entirely on you? Are the books clean?
- Value-gap work. They identify what's dragging the multiple down — thin margins, one fragile ad channel, no email list — and build a plan to fix it before you list.
- Personal and financial goals. They connect the sale to what you actually need from it, so you don't sell too early or for too little.
A consultant does not find you a buyer or negotiate the deal. That's the broker's lane. If you're a year or more out, this is the right hire; if you need to sell now, you'll skip straight to a broker.
What a business broker actually does
A broker is the deal-maker. Once your store is ready, they run the process end to end.
- Valuation and listing. They price the store, usually off Seller's Discretionary Earnings (SDE) for smaller businesses, and build the marketing package.
- Finding buyers. They list on marketplaces, advertise, and work their buyer network to create competition.
- Managing the deal. They field offers, qualify buyers, coordinate due diligence, and shepherd the deal to close.
Brokers typically handle main-street businesses under about $2 million in value and market to individual owner-operators. Above roughly $5 million, that work usually shifts to an M&A advisor who runs a targeted auction to private-equity and strategic buyers, charging a retainer plus a success fee in the low single digits, according to WebsiteClosers. Most POD and Shopify stores sit squarely in broker territory.
Fees: what each one costs you
This is where the choice gets concrete. The two roles are priced completely differently.
A business broker is paid a success fee — a percentage of the sale price, collected only when the store sells. For businesses under a million dollars, that fee commonly runs eight to twelve percent of the sale price, with a minimum fee of roughly $10,000 to $25,000 no matter how small the deal, according to Morgan & Westfield. On larger deals the rate tiers down on a "Double Lehman" scale — ten percent of the first million, then eight, six, four, and two percent on each million after that (same source).
An exit planning consultant is usually paid a flat project fee or a monthly retainer for the preparation work, independent of whether or when you sell. You're buying advice and a roadmap, not a transaction. Some advisory firms fold both together, crediting earlier preparation fees against the final success fee.
The practical takeaway: a broker's fee is contingent and comes out of the sale proceeds; a consultant's fee is an upfront investment you make hoping it lifts the eventual price by more than it costs.
Which one fits an online store at your size
Run the math on your own store before deciding. The decision is almost entirely about readiness and timeline.
If you're a year or more from selling
Say your store does 420 orders a month at a $34 AOV — about $14,280 in monthly revenue — but after Printify costs, Meta spend, and fees your true profit is $4,500 a month, or roughly $54,000 a year in SDE. A buyer values a store on a multiple of that SDE, so every dollar of hidden or recoverable profit you surface before listing moves the sale price.
This is exactly where an exit planning consultant earns their fee. If they help you lift SDE from $54,000 to $72,000 and a buyer pays a 3x multiple, your sale price moves from about $162,000 to $216,000 — a $54,000 swing. That dwarfs the consultant's fee, and it's the whole case for preparing early.
If you're ready to sell now
If your books are clean, profit is stable, and you want out this quarter, skip the consultant and hire a broker. On a $200,000 sale at a ten percent commission, you'd pay about $20,000 — the cost of someone running the listing, screening buyers, and closing the deal while you keep the store running.
The honest counterpoint: if your store is small and simple, a broker's minimum fee can eat a painful share of a modest sale, and some owners sell directly on a marketplace instead. Weigh the commission against how much a broker's buyer competition is likely to raise your final price. Our guide to selling your online business walks the full process either way.
The number both of them will ask for first
Whichever one you hire, the first thing they'll want is your real profit — not revenue, not Shopify's gross figure, but true per-order profit after product cost, shipping, fees, and ad spend. That SDE number is your valuation, and a buyer's due diligence will tear into it.
Most owners can't produce it cleanly, because the numbers live in different places: Shopify, Meta Ads, Google Ads, and Printify, Printful or Gelato never add up in one view. PodVector AI exists to close that gap. Victor is an AI employee who sees every order, every ad dollar, and every supplier cost together, so he computes the true per-order profit on each product and delivers the report to your Google Drive.
That's the number a consultant uses to find value gaps and a broker uses to price your listing. Victor also makes the changes that lift it — he pauses the losing ad set in Meta, reprices the thin-margin SKUs in Shopify, and builds the Klaviyo flow that grows the email list a buyer pays extra for. Dealmakers in a nearby market face the same math whether they sell a business in Las Vegas or online: clean profit sells faster.
Put Victor on your store and walk into any exit conversation with the one number that decides the price.
FAQs
Do I need both an exit planning consultant and a business broker?
Sometimes, but rarely at the same time. If you're a year or more out, a consultant prepares the store; when it's ready, a broker sells it. If you're already sale-ready, you can skip straight to the broker. Hiring both at once usually means paying for preparation you no longer have time to act on.
What's the difference between a business broker and an M&A advisor?
Mostly deal size. Brokers handle smaller main-street businesses — generally under about $2 million — and market to individual buyers, while M&A advisors run larger deals, often $5 million and up, with a targeted auction to private-equity and corporate buyers, according to WebsiteClosers. Most online stores are broker-sized.
How much does a business broker cost to sell a small store?
Expect a success fee of roughly eight to twelve percent of the sale price on businesses under a million dollars, with a minimum fee around $10,000 to $25,000 whatever the sale size, according to Morgan & Westfield. The fee comes out of the proceeds at close, so you pay nothing if the store doesn't sell.
When should I start exit planning for my online store?
Earlier than feels natural — ideally one to three years before you want out. That's enough runway to fix the value gaps a buyer will find: customer concentration, a single fragile ad channel, messy books, or an owner the store can't run without.
Can't I just sell my store myself and skip the fees?
You can, especially for a small, simple store sold on a marketplace. The trade-off is you lose the buyer competition and deal management a broker brings, which often raises the final price by more than the commission costs. Either way, you'll need a defensible profit number first — start with your store valuation.
What makes a store sell for a higher multiple?
Stable, provable profit; diversified traffic instead of one ad account; an owned email list; and documented operations a new owner can step into. These are exactly the gaps exit planning targets, and they're why preparing early tends to pay for itself.