For a small business already doing real sales volume, your own Shopify store is the best place to sell online — it carries the lowest fee per order, and it builds an asset you can one day sell. Marketplaces like Amazon, eBay, and Etsy are worth running alongside it as acquisition channels, not as your home base. The right answer is the mix that protects your margin, and the only way to pick it is to compare the fee stack and the true per-order profit on each one, not the headline "free to list" pitch.

Most "best places to sell online" roundups list the same ten platforms and stop there. That is useless once you have an operating store, because the question you actually face is not where can I list? — it is where do I keep the most of each sale? This article compares the real fee stack on each major platform, walks the same order through four of them, and shows you how to read the number that matters: true per-order profit.

The real question is margin, not reach

Say you run a print-on-demand store doing 340 orders a month at a $31 average order value — roughly $10,500 in monthly revenue. At that volume, a two-point swing in platform fees is about $210 a month, or more than $2,500 a year, straight off your bottom line. The "best" platform is simply the one that leaves the most in your account after fees, product cost, and the ad spend it took to get the sale.

Every platform below sells reach, convenience, or control — and charges for it differently. Your job is to match each channel to what it actually does for your margin.

The fee stack on each platform

Headline fees hide the real cost, because each platform bundles listing, transaction, and payment processing differently. Here is what a small business pays on each major channel in 2026. Shopify's Basic plan runs $39 a month with online card processing of 2.9% plus 30 cents per transaction (Website Builder Expert, Shopify pricing 2026). Amazon charges a referral fee that runs roughly 8% to 15% for most categories, defaulting to 15%, with a 30-cent minimum and payment processing already included (ZonGuru, what percentage does Amazon take). eBay's final value fee is about 12.9% plus 30 cents in most categories, with payment processing bundled into that single fee (AMZScout, eBay selling fees).

Etsy stacks several smaller fees: a $0.20 listing fee, a 6.5% transaction fee on the item plus shipping, and 3% plus 25 cents in US payment processing (Checkout Page, Etsy fees 2026). That lands around ten cents on the dollar before advertising. But Etsy's Offsite Ads program adds 15% to any ad-attributed order, and once your shop passes ten thousand dollars in trailing-year sales that fee becomes a mandatory 12% with no opt-out, which can push Etsy's take toward 22–28% on those orders (Sherocommerce, Etsy to Shopify migration).

Platform What it takes per sale
Shopify (own store) 2.9% + $0.30 processing, plus $39/mo plan
Amazon ~8–15% referral (15% default), $0.30 min, processing included
eBay ~12.9% + $0.30, processing included
Etsy $0.20 listing + 6.5% + (3% + $0.25) ≈ ~10%; +12–15% on Offsite Ads

The sources for every figure in that table are linked in the two paragraphs directly above it. Rates change by category and country, so confirm them in your own seller account before you model a year on them.

The same order, four platforms

Take one order: a $31 shirt that costs you $12 all-in from your Printify supplier (product plus shipping). Here is the platform fee each channel skims off that single sale, using the rates above.

On your own Shopify store, processing is 2.9% × $31 + $0.30 = $0.90 + $0.30 = $1.20. On eBay, 12.9% × $31 + $0.30 = $4.00 + $0.30 = $4.30. On Amazon at the 15% default, 15% × $31 = $4.65. On Etsy without ads, $0.20 + 6.5% × $31 + 3% × $31 + $0.25 = $0.20 + $2.02 + $0.93 + $0.25 = $3.40 — and if that sale came through Offsite Ads, add 15% × $31 = $4.65, taking Etsy's cut to roughly $8.05.

So on an identical $31 order, the platform keeps $1.20 on your own store versus $4.30 to $8.05 on a marketplace. That gap is the price of borrowed traffic.

The honest tradeoff: fee versus built-in demand

Low fees do not automatically win, because a marketplace fee buys something your own store does not come with: shoppers who are already there with their cards out. On your Shopify store you pay only $1.20 to the platform, but you pay separately to bring the customer — say $8 of Meta or Google spend to acquire that order. Your true per-order profit is $31 − $12 product − $1.20 fee − $8 ad spend = $9.80.

On Amazon, the 15% fee is higher, but an organic marketplace sale might cost you far less in advertising — say $2. That order nets $31 − $12 − $4.65 − $2 = $16.35. The marketplace can out-earn your own store on a single sale precisely because the fee is buying demand you would otherwise rent from an ad platform.

The catch is what you don't get on the marketplace: the customer's email, the repeat purchase, the brand. Marketplaces rent you a sale; your own store builds a customer list and a business you own. That is why the operator answer is usually "both" — your store as the margin-rich home base, marketplaces as paid acquisition that you measure like any other channel.

Your store is also the asset you eventually sell

The channel you control is the only one that accrues into something you can cash out. A Shopify store with its own customer list, repeat-purchase history, and brand is a sellable asset; an Amazon or Etsy presence that lives on someone else's platform is far harder to transfer. When you want to understand what that asset is worth, start with how a Shopify store is valued, which breaks down the multiples buyers actually pay.

When you reach the exit, the "best place to sell" question returns in a different form — this time it is where to list the business. The options range from curated brokers to open marketplaces, and the right venue depends on your size and clean-ness of books; our guide to the best marketplaces to sell a Shopify store and the overview of how to sell your online business walk through each path end to end.

Where PodVector AI fits

The reason most sellers can't answer "which channel is best" is that the numbers live in different places — sales in Shopify, ad spend in Meta and Google, product cost in Printify, Printful, or Gelato. PodVector AI's Victor is an AI employee who pulls all of that together and computes your true per-order profit on every product and every channel, so you can see which platform is actually paying you.

Victor doesn't stop at the number. He pauses the losing ad set in Meta and Google Ads, reprices the thin-margin SKUs in Shopify, builds and sends the Klaviyo flow that turns a first marketplace buyer into a repeat customer on your own store, and drafts the customer-support email when an order goes sideways. He delivers the profit-by-channel report straight to your Google Drive. If you want the margin math done for you across every place you sell, put Victor to work on your store.

FAQs

What is the single best place for a small business to sell online?

For an operating store, your own Shopify store is the best home base: it carries the lowest fee per order — roughly 2.9% plus 30 cents in processing on the Basic plan (Website Builder Expert) — and it builds a customer list and brand you own. Treat Amazon, eBay, and Etsy as acquisition channels you add on top, not as a replacement for the store you control.

Is it cheaper to sell on my own store or on a marketplace?

On fees alone, your own store wins easily — about $1.20 in processing on a $31 order versus $4.30 on eBay or $4.65 on Amazon at the default rate. But the marketplace fee includes built-in traffic, while on your store you pay for that traffic separately through ads. Compare them on true per-order profit after ad spend, not on the headline fee.

How much does Etsy really take per sale?

Without advertising, Etsy's combined listing, transaction, and payment fees come to roughly ten cents on the dollar (Checkout Page). Offsite Ads add 15% to ad-attributed orders, and above ten thousand dollars in trailing-year sales that fee is a mandatory 12% with no opt-out, which can push Etsy's total take toward 22–28% on those sales (Sherocommerce).

Should I sell on multiple platforms at once?

Usually yes, if you track each channel's real profit. Running your own store plus one or two marketplaces lets the marketplaces feed you demand while your store captures the margin and the repeat purchase. The risk is that fees, returns, and ad costs vary so much by channel that your blended profit hides which one is actually losing money — which is exactly the thing per-channel profit tracking is for.

Does a marketplace sale ever beat my own store on profit?

Yes. A single organic Amazon or eBay sale can out-earn a Shopify sale because the higher fee replaces the ad spend you'd otherwise pay to acquire the customer. The place your own store wins over time is the customer relationship — the email, the brand, and the repeat orders that a marketplace keeps for itself.

What's the best place to sell the business itself later?

That depends on your revenue and how clean your books are, and it is a separate decision from where you sell your products. Curated brokers suit larger, higher-margin stores, while open marketplaces fit smaller ones; see how to sell your online business, the breakdown of marketplaces to sell a Shopify store, and the regional view in selling an online business in Las Vegas.